Russia's Army
A History from the Napoleonic Wars to the War in Ukraine
By Roger R. Reese, and Reviewed by Gene M. Harding
Article published on:
in the Winter 2026
edition of Army History
Read Time:
< 5 mins
University of Oklahoma Press, 2023
Pp. xiv, 225. $34.95
Perhaps no book could be timelier in its publication than
Russia’s Army:
A History from the Napoleonic Wars to the War in Ukraine by Roger
R. Reese. Currently a professor at the University of Texas A&M, Reese
has written several works on the Russian Army, with the majority focusing
on the Soviet era. All students of military history or current events will
benefit from reading any of his works, but Russia’s Army is where
they should begin their journey. In its entirety,
Russia’s Army covers a little over two centuries of military
history, focusing on the continuous changes that led to today’s modern
Russian Army.
The book begins in 1801 with an examination of the reigns of Tsar
Alexander I and his brother and successor, Nicholas I. During this time,
the empire’s military was still in its infancy. The tsar, when visible on
the battlefield, was in sole command, with the aristocracy forming the
officer class. Conscripted serfs made up the soldiery. Unlike in many of
the Western armies, these soldiers were forced to serve twenty-five years
in the army, and often never saw their homes again because of the high
mortality rate on the battlefield. In short, they were forced to exchange
a life of servitude in support of the Russian state for one fighting its
wars.
By beginning his work here, Reese illustrates the Russian Army’s state
prior to the Napoleonic Wars (13). He also sets the stage for a series of
ongoing military reforms that would continue well into the twentieth
century (160). This history is told throughout the book, and the story of
the serfs and their struggle also reemerges across chapters, emerging as
the catalyst that ultimately leads to the revolution and overthrow of the
Romanov dynasty.
Throughout the first four chapters of the book, we see a series of
incidents in which the Russian Army, believing in victory because of its
numerical superiority, fails (76). At first glance, leadership and a lack
of planning appear to be the army’s undoing. Upon deeper inspection,
logistics, multiple fronts to defend, a lack of modernization, and
internal strife were chief contributors to this failure. For any army
invading Russia, the timeless challenge has always been the country’s
size. What is not stated is that this size was also a constant Achilles’
heel for the Russians themselves (81). At critical moments during the
eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the immense size of Russia tested its
leadership’s governance abilities to the near breaking point. The strain,
in turn, led to widespread civil unrest.
This civil unrest eventually led to the most dynamic change for the
Russian people. As Western ideology spread to the East, the Russian people
experienced a philosophical awakening (103). Education became increasingly
standard for the officer class. This awareness then spread to the rank and
file of the army and led to growing animosity against the tsar and the
ruling class.
After the period of the tsars, Reese gives a powerful overview of the army
during the years leading up to and through the Soviet era. The final three
chapters are dedicated to the telling of this part of Russian history.
Building on the foundation of unrest and awakening, here we again see the
story of the serf. This class had been oppressed for the past two
centuries, and the Bolshevik movement in 1917 sought to bring about
equality. The toll of the First World War was great, and enthusiasm to
follow the new philosophy fell short. The Treaty of Brest-Litovsk was the
result (105). Though the treaty was humiliating for Vladimir Lenin and the
Bolsheviks, it produced a sort of reset for the future Soviet Army. Reese
again takes the reader through a seemingly dark period of history, where
the mettle of the newly established Russian Communist Party and the
military is tested. This testing lasts through a civil war and conflicts
with neighboring nations. It is during the 1920s and 1930s when, Reese
argues, the Army experienced a major transformation. This transformation
was a major leap forward before Josef Stalin imposed the Great Purge on
the military. Though the purge had lasting effects, the Second World War
became the catalyst that would guide military thinking for the duration of
the Soviet era.
Following the Allied powers’ victory in the Second World War, Reese makes
a subliminal argument that the Soviet Union clung to its laurels and
always referred to its victories to validate its future (135). As history
tells us, however, this all came to an end in the 1990s when the Soviet
Union fell apart, and from its ashes came the Russian Federation. The
irony is that the status of the common Russian soldier reverted to what it
had been before 1917. Once again, the rank and file largely were composed
of people from the countryside, who were poor and without prospects.
Reese makes his final argument in showing that the Russian military has
not truly learned from its often turbulent history. The army that fights
today is not too different from the army of one or two hundred years ago.
He reinforces this fact through his analysis of the latest wars and
conflicts in which Russia has been involved.
In closing, this book is an incredible work that should be read for
several reasons. Whether readers want to learn the history of the Russian
Army in its transformative years or attempt to understand the culture and
mindset of the modern Russian soldier, they will not be displeased. Reese
does an expert job of not bogging the reader down in the details, instead
taking them through the highlights of the Russian Army and its history.
Finally, he leaves the reader with an expert analysis of the burden borne
by the common soldiery. It was, after all, their efforts that allowed the
land we know as Russia to be in existence to this day.
Authors
Maj. Gene M. Harding is the executive officer for the
1st Battalion, 293d Infantry, in Fort Wayne, Indiana. During his career,
he has served at all echelons from platoon to joint level. Before
becoming an active duty soldier, he was a high school and university
history teacher. He holds multiple master’s degrees and has completed
doctoral work in ancient history, applied behavioral analysis in
psychology, and holocaust and genocidal studies.